While I’m no expert at all the nuances of WordPress, ESPECIALLY the newest version 2.7, I do know a little bit about it. As my dad used to say “You can put all I know in a thimble and still have room for your finger in there.”
Anyway, back to the point. I have used popup comments for a long time. I guess it’s a carry over from when I used to use first Blogger and later Movable Type (no, I’m NOT going back). But I like them. It gives you the ability to look at the post in the original window of your browser and make your comment in a new, smaller window that “housed” all of the comments and the comment form. I like that and my themes have all used the popup comment form – all that I had to do was remove the commenting from one line of php in the head section and the popup comment form was used.
Why am I saying all this? Well, after much searching and checking of sources I have come to the conclusion that the new commenting features in WordPress 2.7 are NOT available when using the popup comment form. If there are any WordPress Jockeys reading this, please inform me if I’m wrong and point me to where an explanation is of how to use the new features (threading and replying to comments) on popup comments.
What that means is that when I update my themes to use WordPress 2.7, I’ll include legacy support which will use popup comments on WordPress versions older than 2.7 and on-page comments with WordPress 2.7 and newer. This is not a bad thing, but it is a change for me as a theme designer; and, it’s more than change for the sake of change.


















